Friday, October 31, 2008

POSSESSION IS 3/4ths OF THE LAW.

Last night, I received a phone call from an associate. She needed some advice about a landlord/tenant issue. I get a lot of phone calls asking for advice. So, I figured I would share those questions. In a confidential nature of course!!:)


So, anyway she obtained an apartment in Brooklyn, NY through a real estate agent. She paid the agent's commission, got the keys, and moved into the apartment.


For two months, she's been living in the apartment without a lease. Coincidentally, the building was sold to a new owner. She tried numerous times to contact the agent and the new management company. However, neither has returned her messages.


Whoooaa!! So, here are the facts:

  • New management
  • No written lease
  • No news of signing a lease agreement
  • Possession of the apartment for 2 months

I stated to my friend, "Possession is 3/4ths of the Law."


It's a rule of law I learned during my first year of law school in Property. Under Anglo-Saxon law, the person who has physical possession of a THING has first rights to claim it. First rights gives you "legal" possession of the THING. (Johnson v. McIntosh)

Although she does not have a lease, she has legal possession of the property which translates into greater protection for her under the law. Despite not having a lease, she is not as powerless as she thinks.

I advised her to write a letter to the new managment company requesting a lease agreement.

I instructed her to mail the letter certified with return receipt postage; allow management at least two weeks to respond; and if there is no response, she should consult a lawyer for further advice.



Disclaimer: This blog entry is not written as legal advice

1 comment:

eLbie said...

LOL @ 'disclaimer' you're such a legal beagle!!!